Title: Did you ever get healed? | |
Revival_Centres_Discussion_Forums > Bible, Beliefs, Scriptures and 'The Word' > Revival Doctrines we 'USED TO BELIEVE' | Go to subcategory: |
Author | Content |
MothandRust | |
Date Posted:29/07/2006 12:06 AMCopy HTML Once you've gone throught the belief system and buy into the whole thing you start to believe in all the fringe benefits... like healing.
Time to accessorise that amazing tongue trick with the other gifts, signs and fruits. Perhaps that dicky knee can be replaced... perhaps the fatty tissues bringing death closer can be slowed down? Of course you could start eating properly and exercise, but a quick fix and the prayer line would make it all a whole lot easier. Ah yes, throw away the Rosary beads and take two tonguesand see me in the morning if Cancer still persists. Guaranteed it is that life will change dramatically and sometimes an ailment is actually 'healed' and the pain is gone. You can reallign your life and make resolutions fuelled by an amazing over night healing that we can all suppose came from God above. Well, why not? The power of positive thinking, the placebo effect, that kind of thing. But psychologists report that the euphoria will wear off in a short matter of time, and the failure to follow through on any of the resolutions will leave people even more demoralized than ever. But they'll be back ? the people who fall for these things do so again and again. One woman seen at a Revival meeting seemed to see no irony in the fact that she'd been attending the same meetings regularly for three years without results. I've seen people convinced that God wanted to heal people and make idiots of themselves trying to raise somebody out of a wheel chair. I've seen people convinced that God was going to reward them if they increased their giving to the church, and they just wound up more broke than ever. Do they learn? Nope, they figure that they must have some sin, or something they've missed, not enough prayer, etc. Sometimes prayer works. Sometimes it doesn't. I have heard many second-hand stories that open the possibilities that there was a dynamic involved that was not explainable by the doctor. Certainly never seen anything in my 35 years of wandering that looked slightly supernatural in any way. Instagram and Twitter: @mothpete
|
|
steamylee | Share to: #1 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:30/07/2006 6:39 AMCopy HTML when my brother (now 11) was born, he was diagnosed as severly epileptic, one of the worst cases these doctors had ever seen, to cut a long story short mum and dad prayed and fasted for a week, and when they went back to the doctors there was no sign of epilepsy. this isnt just something that just goes away, especially when the person having the fits is having 6ish fits a day. i believe that he was healed, and that it was by god. |
|
MothandRust | Share to: #2 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:30/07/2006 5:41 PMCopy HTML
I wonder what would have happened if they didn't fast? Or pray for that matter? Always makes me wonder. Prayer should really be unnecessary when there is an all-knowing, and all-powerful God. Suppose a famous and gifted doctor happened to be your friend and that he had the ability to cure any sickness known. Now suppose you had a baby that became desperately sick in the presence of this super-doctor, what would you expect him to do? If the baby is choking, for example, you would expect him to help out and save the baby from dying. You wouldn't expect him to ask you first if you believed or had faith that he could cure your child before he was willing to help. You'd expect the super-doctor to act as soon as he sees it choking. Ok, let's also say that this doctor could stop cancer in all children, anywhere in the world, before it occurs. You'd expect him to do it... because he's "good." But if he does do it, then you wouldn't expect there to be any cases of children getting cancer. If the super-doctor has this ability, then he shouldn't wait for anyone to ask him. We would expect him to act out of pure goodness asap! Similarly, an all-good guy God wouldn't want anyone to suffer. He would know who would suffer ahead of time, and prevent it before it happens and there wouldn't be any need for prayer in the first place, especially if it's used to heal the sick and stop suffering. I'm sure there are many and various theological theories as to why God has such a messed up system. Seems pretty random to me. Instagram and Twitter: @mothpete
|
|
MothandRust | Share to: #3 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:30/07/2006 7:02 PMCopy HTML Why people put trust in hopeFor most of my life, I believed in healing, the fundy pentecostal Revival way. I witnessed what I thought were miracle healings, cures from cancer, restored lawnmowers(!) and the like. I hear lots of nice stories from other people that sort of remind me of what it's like talking to people convinced they've seen a UFO or a ghost. I've learned a lot about why people believe in answered prayers, even when it's completely illogical. Every single case of a supposedly answered prayer that I've witnessed can be explained by one or more of the following:
In DOC we trust... Many "sick conditions" get better on their own because the body has mechanisms to relieve itself (e.g., fevers, high blood pressure, colds etc). Other supposed illnesses that we are told cannot be healed naturally possibly can be. The medical profession is often confounded by our body's ability to bounce back from inconceivable situations. Again, all these factors make it very simplistic to call a miracle what is more likely the result of human error about a prognosis or a diagnosis. there are many cases in which a doctor might tell a patient that he or she has an incurable illness from which death will occur within a short period of time. At the end of this period, the patient is not only alive, but much better. This turn of events will usually be attributed to a divine healing. Yet the patient may overlook the fact that the doctor's diagnosis may have been wrong in the first place. Yep, these 'miracle' healings occur in and out of churches all the time. Evenif you recovered from a deadly illness more quickly and better than expected, you still can't know if it was God. The most ya could say is that the recovery was accomplished through an unknown process. Many healings that may appear supernaturally miraculous may be due to very natural processes which have not been recognised or studied previously. Indeed, one can draw up a long list of phenomena that were unknown 100 years ago but are deemed perfectly natural today. In fact, most believers in prayer have received conventional medical treatment, and so one cannot eliminate the possibility that it was the medical treatment, not the prayer, that actually had a beneficial effect, even when such an effect might be unexpected. Peer group agreement Another reason for the belief in healing among Christians is the wild and wacky 'event' type church services where healings are given 'life'. The psychology of the miracle seeker is also a factor. If the pastor asks the patient if God has healed them, they are likely to say "Yes," even if their symptoms say the opposite. Many times, people will say that they have been healed because they really believe that eventually God will heal them. Don't want to admit your faith isn't up to scratch. Instagram and Twitter: @mothpete
|
|
Torrack | Share to: #4 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:13/08/2006 5:40 AMCopy HTML In response to the title of this thread, I would like to tell the story of my healing as it happened to me last August at a camp in the Vancouver branch of the GRC. It's a long post but if you want a short version, here you go: Last summer my foot was healed in less than 8 hours after I either sprained it or broke it, and it happened when I prayed. fficeffice" /> I was scheduled to give a sermon at the morning meeting, and I had gone to my mother's Caravan to change and have some breakfast beforehand. As I exited the Caravan, I placed my left foot on some uneven ground and rolled my foot so that the sole of my foot was facing up towards the sky and I had all of my weight on the base of the bones of my lower leg for a moment. I heard and felt things (bones?) crack and pop all at once. Needless to say, the pain was excruciating and I ended up writhing on the ground rather quickly. Paster Ivermee from Australia arrived shortly thereafter and laid his hands on me and prayed in tongues and in English. However the pain remained at that time. I went on with the sermon, limped around a bit, but really tried to stay off my foot as much as possible for most of that day. I spent much of the afternoon in my mother's caravan, and when I tried at about 4pm to walk, the pain seemed much worse than before. My foot at that time was badly swollen and extremely bruised, and it certainly felt like I had at least sprained it, if not broken it. Now I had been taught that if you don't get healed right away, that the person is lacking in faith, so I got mad at myself and decided that I was going to pray until it was healed. So I made my way to the prayer tent, and prayed on my knees in tongues for about 30 minutes. At that point I thought: "How can I know if it's healed if I'm not using my foot?" so I started walking around the small prayer tent step by step. The first step was, to my surprise, not very painful and I heard some popping and cracking. The second step was even less painful, accompanied by more popping and cracking. In all, the pain lasted about 4 or 5 steps and the cracking for about 5 or 6 more after that. Once the sensations had stopped, and I could walk normally, I began jumping up and down on my left foot, and it was fine. Then I ran around the small tent, and that too was fine. I was amazed, and delighted at the apparent miracle that had just transpired. I must say that while I could walk, run and jump without pain or hindrance from then on, the swelling and terrible bruising remained for some time afterwards, a little more than a week if I remember correctly. I actually liked that because for the next few days I would show people my foot, and then jump and run around to show that it was healed, even though it looked really horrible. Now it's true, I didn't seek out any medical help, I saw no doctors and had no examinations at any hospital, so the only form of record for the injury is my own memory and those that saw my foot at that camp last year. But I do believe that it was a healing from God. Sure, it's possible that was simply mind over matter, or my body simply healed itself, but I wonder why my body would have chosen that particular step to start popping things back into order, and not the several-dozen others that I had taken earlier that day in extreme pain? I don't know, but I choose to believe it was God, or at least something supernatural and powerful that we humans do not fully understand. I guess that sounds to me like a description of God. I have no illusions that I will convince anybody that it was an actual supernatural healing, but I thought I would share the experience with you just the same.
http://www.filecabi.net/video/atheist-delusion.html
|
|
steamylee | Share to: #5 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:13/08/2006 8:00 AMCopy HTML
|
|
MothandRust | Share to: #6 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:13/08/2006 2:37 PMCopy HTML
Miracles do happen... it's just that they always seem to happen to other people... bizarre things are reported all the time around the world. The bloody crop circles confuse the hell outta me. I've read of ear-drum miracles from a lot of different people. I need an ear miracle myself... severely... I hope one would come my way for my ears. I really do.. if I do get one, you'll hear from me.
Instagram and Twitter: @mothpete
|
|
dogmafree | Share to: #7 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:13/08/2006 2:58 PMCopy HTML On a slightly lighter note........
I recall some years ago, a pastor gave a rousing talk about the power of God to heal. Having got the juices of inspiration going, he called upon anyone to stand up and declare what healings they have themselves experienced at the hand of God. One person stood and announced "migraines", then another and another stood testifying what ailment they'd been delivered from. An elderly woman then taking her turn, stood and boldly decared "blue, strangulated haemmorhoids"! Well, the moment was magic! All self control went out the window as the hall burst out with spontaneaous laughter, for all of about, maybe 4-5 seconds before we all composed ourselves once again. Needless to say, I didn't have the benefit of witnessing this amazing miracle for myself! the Dog. "for there is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so" Shakespeare (Hamlet, Act 2, Scene 2)
|
|
groo | Share to: #8 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:12/02/2007 12:32 AMCopy HTML There was a major accident once, at a Moruya camp (either a kid's camp, or a kid's activity at another camp), it would have been 1987 or 88. Four or five girls (K. Kirwood was one, I recall) were hurt really badly after some bleachers collapsed, IIRC there were some spinal fractures and the like, and they were all up and walking again in a very short period of time. Their healing was attributed to miracles, but I don't know enough of the medical details to be able to comment personally.
|
|
break free | Share to: #9 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:20/02/2007 6:26 PMCopy HTML i had one real miraculous healing and it wasnt in the revival centers. i injured my back when i was 14, during a limbo competition with my sister lol always funny when having to explain how i hurt myself . anyway i fell to the ground and couldnt move my dad picked me up and put the bones back into place and prayd for me. from that point on i had pain, sometimes worse than others. i had something called siatica where a nerve gets pinched by the bones in the back.when i was pregnat with my son (think giant baby lol) i had to go to an ostio once a week so i could walk esp in the later part of the pregnacy. 14 years later i was prayed for in a healing line from that point on the pain was gone and it has never come back- despite my addiction to 6 inch heels and thats why i dont do the limbo lol
its also why you should always have vidio proof.... i won that competition damn it!!! but my sis insisted i had cheated so to prove her wrong i not only did it again i went even lower- to this day i am the rightfull owner of the title limbo queen |
|
outaegypt | Share to: #10 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:20/02/2007 9:34 PMCopy HTML REPLY TO Break Free: despite my addiction to 6 inch heels
Hey Break Free, Im really hoping your female right about now!!! As I hear it, I'll repeat it,
Its up to you if you believe it!
Allegation big and small,
soon revealed before us all.
outa here- Outa Egypt!
|
|
break free | Share to: #11 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:20/02/2007 9:52 PMCopy HTML
damn now i wish i could say i wasnt lol no im definatly female- well last time i checked anyway.... hmmmmmmmmm maybe i should check again..... never know what might happen when you not looking |
|
MothandRust | Share to: #12 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:19/03/2007 4:54 PMCopy HTML This excerpt illustrates what I've been posting on the subject: Excerpt (Click here) (The) introduction is to help show that I was very active and believed that I was indeed, a "True Christian." And that's why when I had a miracle, I was extremely grateful, but not overly surprised. My god was a mighty god, after all, who reigned from heaven on high. Miracles were a normal part of my theology. Instagram and Twitter: @mothpete
|
|
MothandRust | Share to: #13 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:31/03/2007 10:40 PMCopy HTML .: posted 4/01/2007 ::: by .:webmaster:. ::: EmailThis! ?/SMALL> A blast from a year ago: Christians pray for heart-surgery patients In the largest study of its kind, researchers found that having people pray for heart bypass surgery patients had no effect on their recovery. In fact, patients who knew they were being prayed for had a slightly higher rate of complications. Researchers emphasized that their work can't address whether God exists or answers prayers made on another's behalf. The study can only look for an effect from prayers offered as part of the research, they said. They also said they had no explanation for the higher complication rate in patients who knew they were being prayed for, in comparison to patients who only knew it was possible prayers were being said for them. Critics said the question of God's reaction to prayers simply can't be explored by scientific study. The work, which followed about 1,800 patients at six medical centers, was financed by the Templeton Foundation, which supports research into science and religion. It will appear in the American Heart Journal. Dr. Herbert Benson of Harvard Medical School and other scientists tested the effect of having three Christian groups pray for particular patients, starting the night before surgery and continuing for two weeks. The volunteers prayed for "a successful surgery with a quick, healthy recovery and no complications" for specific patients, for whom they were given the first name and first initial of the last name. The patients, meanwhile, were split into three groups of about 600 apiece: those who knew they were being prayed for, those who were prayed for but only knew it was a possibility, and those who weren't prayed for but were told it was a possibility. The researchers didn't ask patients or their families and friends to alter any plans they had for prayer, saying such a step would have been unethical and impractical. The study looked for any complications within 30 days of the surgery. Results showed no effect of prayer on complication-free recovery. But 59 percent of the patients who knew they were being prayed for developed a complication, versus 52 percent of those who were told it was just a possibility. Dr. Harold G. Koenig, director of the Center for Spirituality, Theology and Health at the Duke University Medical Center, who didn't take part in the study, said the results didn't surprise him. "There are no scientific grounds to expect a result and there are no real theological grounds to expect a result either," he said. "There is no god in either the Christian, Jewish or Muslim scriptures that can be constrained to the point that they can be predicted." Within the Christian tradition, God would be expected to be concerned with a person's eternal salvation, he said, and "why would God change his plans for a particular person just because they're in a research study?" Science, he said, "is not designed to study the supernatural." Instagram and Twitter: @mothpete
|
|
MothandRust | Share to: #14 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:04/08/2007 8:02 PMCopy HTML In this scientific experiment, it is totally proven that prayer is awesome, and God exists! The numbers don't lie...
Instagram and Twitter: @mothpete
|
|
Uncoolman | Share to: #15 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:20/11/2008 1:51 PMCopy HTML A very interesting topic. The video was too. I think it highlights a lot of beliefs people can have and hang on to, simply because they feel the need to believe them. Not believing them is an idea too scary so they search out supporting "evidence" which provides them with comfort. People seem also to have a habit of misattributing emotions (such as the comfort) as proof or evidence. But a saying in psychology which i stand by, "just because you feel something doesnt make it true".
I was brought up Anglican and have suffered many severe health issues including cot death. I was clinically dead for so long my prognosis was that I would be a vegetable. Yet here I am studying a doctorate in psychology. A mircale? Or just the amazing plasticity of the brain at such a young age which allows undamagd areas to take over the functions of the damaged areas? From birth I experienced many ear problems - had tonsils removed and gromits put in several times. Every time I got sick as a kid my eustacean tube would block up and cause hours of pain before finally rupturing. It got to the point where if i got a snuffly nose I would get quite anxious that it meant I was going to end up with my ear drum bursting again. When I was ten my mother was going away. We had our pastor come and lay hands on me and we prayed that for the 2 months mum would be away that I would be free of such ear infections. 18 years later and I've never had a ruptured eardrum again. Nor have I experienced earache (apart from on descending in a plane) again. Quite astounding and I did consider it a miracle. It still blows my mind but I'm less convinced about it being miraculous. I had laying on of hands a 2nd time after suffering chronic fatigue for some time. There was no sudden fix, to my dismay. But within a few weeks we found a doctor who ultimately led me on the road to recovery and I have never looked back. But chances are I'd have found that doctor anyway. I was suffering and we were searching for help. It makes sense that we found it. When my dog was 12 her liver was riddled with cancer. Scans showed the vets she had no hope. We asked what could be done and our kind vet answered honestly and said "pray for a miracle". She then said shed keep or dog for the weekend and open her up on the monday, and explained that she wouldnt survive the anaesthetic. I got onto christian chat sites and IRC rooms and asked everyone to pray for my dog. I wasnt ready to let her go. She was fit and healthy aside from her failing liver. The next week our miracle happened and she did a poo. The sign the vet had told us would indicate survival. That week we took her home and she lived another 4 precious years. I definitaley thought it had to be a miracle. especially when another vet at that practice, who hadnt seen our dog before, read her file at a check up said "this cant be the same dog - this dog should be dead". But how can I explain that as a miracle when I think about the rare genetic condition I was born with. Symptoms from conception and suffered all my life. Psychological suffering from being undiagnosed and not being believed. Sure, I got my diagnosis which was the best thing to happen in my life. I was very furtunate to be diagnosed as young as 19. I was fortunate to be diagnosed at all. Was being diagnosed a miracle? If there are miracles then why can't I have some of the physical pain taken away from me? and what about all the tragedy that has struck innocent little Sophie Delizio?! Her experiences are enough to make one questions God's existence all together. I dont know - but it seems some incredibly miraculous like things happen every now and then - to good people and bad. And some horrificly awful things happen as well - also to good people as well as bad. I find it hard to say some of the good things are miracles because doesnt that mean then that those suffering arent getting miracles for a reason? and u cant tell me they are undeserving! oh doesnt all this just do your head in?! lol thinks its time i get some sleep! :) |
|
Uncoolman | Share to: #16 |
Re:Did you ever get healed? Date Posted:20/11/2008 2:58 PMCopy HTML ps - i have never spoken in tongues nor even witnessed anyone doing so (except on tv which I always found unnerving). so according to GRC doctrines those miraculous like events in my life couldnt possibly be miracles cos I was in the wrong church and did not posess "the gift". (never mind that i had a strong faith and a personal relationship with God at the time). |